The main focus of the criticisms raised by O’Kelly and Soltani (2025) (hereafter referred to as discussers) to the authors’ article in Bulletin of Mineral Research and Exploration (174, 1-10) is to examine the veracity of the strength-based equations presented by Kayabalı et al. (2024). The discussers applied the predictive equations proposed by the authors to dissimilar soils in the two articles (Kayabalı et al., 2015a; Kayabalı et al., 2015b) published earlier by the lead author with his research group. The discussers showed that the predictive equations 6 and 7 given by Kayabalı et al. (2024) yield extremely high values of liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) when applied to dissimilar soils. Further, discussers argued that the approach proposed
by Kayabalı et al. (2024) led to erroneous results in determining soil classes.
Latest Pliocene-Quaternary uplift of the central Tauride and Evolutionary history of the Kızıllar Canyon, southern central Anatolia-Türkiye
Authors:
Ali KOÇYİĞİT, Uğur DOĞAN
ABSTRACT
The study area is located near the apex of the north-facing and V-shaped Konya-Niğde Graben. Its south-southeast margin is defined and controlled by the NE-trending Karaman-Niğde Fault Zone. It also forms the geographic boundary between the central Tauride in the south and central Anatolia in the north. This study aimed to determine the Latest Pliocene-Quaternary uplift rate of the central Tauride and the evolutionary history of the Kızıllar Canyon located on the uplifting southern footwall block of the Karaman Niğde Fault Zone. Both the geological and geomorphological field data, which were obtained within the framework of this study, revealed the following: (1) the Kızıllar River drainage system developed as a result of several capture events; (2) Lithological and hydrological characteristics of the valley reveal the reason for the lack of gradation in the river’s longitudinal profile; (3) the Kızıllar Canyon reflects the incision process of the Kızıllar River; (4) the Kızıllar River cut vertically into its bed up to 230 m, which corresponds to the minimum Latest Pliocene- Quaternary uplift rate of the central Tauride (~0.06 mm/yr); and (5) the Kızıllar Canyon developed as a natural response of the river to the uplift of the Konya-Niğde Fault Zone footwall block.
Keywords:
Kızıllar Canyon, Central Taurides, Central Anatolia, Fault, Uplift Rate
The Dodurga Fault is an active right-lateral strike-slip fault, approximately 63 km long, striking NW-SE in northwestern Anatolia. Based on 1:25,000-scale active fault mapping, the fault is subdivided into two principal geometric segments. Segment 1 is approximately 16 km long and extends from Sulhiye in the west to Erikli in the east, whereas Segment 2 is 47 km long and is characterized by a right-stepping geometry and a 10°-15° southeastern deflection. Geological and geomorphological observations, together with kinematic analyses, indicate that the fault is dominantly right-lateral strike-slip in character. Stream channels offset by up to several kilometers along the fault trace support its long-term activity, and fault-plane kinematic indicators independently confirm dextral motion. Paleostress analyses of the kinematic data indicate that the recent deformation phase along the Dodurga Fault is governed by approximately N-S contraction and E-W extension. Empirical scaling relationships suggest that Segment 1 and Segment 2 are capable of generating earthquakes of Mw 6.47 and Mw 6.97, respectively. If both segmentsrupture together, the Dodurga Fault could potentially generate an earthquake of Mw 7.16.
Modeling the discharge of Kapuzbaşı spring for parameterization of the karst aquifer, Aladağ Mountains, Central Taurus, Türkiye
Authors:
Süleyman Selim ÇALLI
ABSTRACT
Kapuzbaşı karst spring is located between Kayseri and Adana, one of the most important and wellstudied mountainous karst regions, Aladağlar, Central Taurus, Türkiye. Previous scientific studies revealed the hydrogeological setup, perceptual model including groundwater residence time and potential recharge-discharge relationship; however, there has not been any process-based conceptual
modeling experiment on the karst spring aiming to parameterize the karst system hydrodynamics. In the present study, we aimed to develop a numerical model of the karst groundwater system to parameterize the system hydrodynamics, which was built based on the conceptual understanding of the karst hydrogeology. We selected the lumped-conceptual hydrological model of KarstMod to quantify the discharge of the Kapuzbaşı spring. The modeling experiment showed that the recharge area of the karst spring is covering approximately 350 km2, and the approximate annual discharge exceeds 250 hm3. The preferential flow mechanism triggered after the water level in epikarst exceeding 92 mm, and the melt factor is approximated as 9.91 mm/°C/day. The response time of conduit reservoir is approximately 1 day, and the loss flux triggered when the water level in conduit reservoir exceeding 4 mm. The hydraulic conductivity of the matrix reservoir is found approx. 0.012 mm/day. The model performance based on the daily discharge was obtained as Nash Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) = 0.77, and Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) = 0.87 in the calibration, and NSE = 0.76, and KGE = 0.77 for the validation periods, respectively. Eliminating the less sensitive model parameters in the calibration leads to more robust and less uncertain discharge simulations.
Keywords:
Kapuzbaşı Karst Spring, Aladağ Mountains, Hydrological Model, KarstMod, Central Taurus
Effect of calculated dry rock bulk modulus on uncertainty in compressional wave velocities derived from Gassmann fluid substitution theory and fluid mixing law in a CO2 sequestration case
Authors:
Mustafa Berkay DOĞAN
ABSTRACT
This study examines the effect of variations in dry rock bulk modulus (Kdry) on compressional wave velocity (Vp) using Gassmann fluid substitution theory and various fluid mixing laws in the context of CO2 sequestration in the Utsira formation at the Sleipner Field. Significant changes in Vp, exceeding 600 m/s, were observed, particularly when applying the Gassmann-Wood law, which demonstrated heightened sensitivity to saturation variations. In contrast, the Gassmann-Brie approach, utilizing an empirically selected constant, produced more stable and reliable results. This study emphasizes that relying solely on the Gassmann-Wood equation for Kdry calculations may result in inaccurate predictions, particularly for CO2-saturated formations. To mitigate this, laboratory measurements of Kdry are recommended to enhance the reliability of predictions. Furthermore, initial saturation conditions critically affect the Vp calculations, underlining the importance of selecting an appropriate mixing law to ensure accurate assessments during CO2 injection and storage.
Fahmy O. MOHAMMED, Ahmed Ibraheem MOHAMED, Ibrahim H. GART, Diary A . Al-MANMI
Indexed In · Volume 176 / April 2025
Establishing of soil loss tolerance limit and sediment yield in Zagros fold-thrust belt: a case study in the Kanarwe river basin, Iraq-Iran
Authors:
Fahmy O. MOHAMMED, Ahmed Ibraheem MOHAMED, Ibrahim H. GART, Diary A . Al-MANMI
ABSTRACT
Soil degradation is a significant cause of topsoil loss; in most mountainous region watersheds, it leads to decreased agriculture productivity and reservoir storage. This study targeted calculating and mapping soil loss and sediment yield in the Lesser Zab watershed located between Iraq and Iran. The Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE) model was used to calculate the soil loss. A Digital Elevation Model of 30m, a Digital Soil map (1:500000), rainfall, and land cover were used to derive parameters. The soil loss rates are 58.1 and 0.1 tha-1yr-1. The total annual soil loss is 1037289 tonnes, of these 404512, covering 75% of Kanarwe river basin land. Most of these affected lands are in the eastern and middle part, which is below the FAOs standard allowable for tolerable soil erosion. Still, the rest covers 25 % of the basin in the west with a total annual soil loss equal to 632777 tonnes, above FAOs standard. The maximum and minimum sediment yield is 29 and 0.1 tha-1yr-1, respectively. Based on the statistical correlation coefficient, the most effective RUSLE parameters on sediment yield from high to low are topography 0.48, soil erodibility 0.38, and crop management 0.38.
Keywords:
RUSLE, Sediment Delivery, Zagros Thrust Zone, CN-SCS Curve, Dam Lifespan.
Magnetic anomalies and geological signatures in the Black Sea: a comprehensive study of the east and west basins
Authors:
İlkin ÖZSÖZ, Eşref AYLAN, Ceyhan Ertan TOKER
ABSTRACT
This study investigates the origin of the Black Sea, focusing on the East and West Black Sea basins. Data such as Curie Point Depth values, heat flow, bathymetry, Moho depth, sediment thickness, and magnetic depth estimation were analyzed to explore the region’s geological features. Correlations between these parameters were assessed for each basin, shedding light on their tectonic history and the influence of volcanic rocks. Thinner sedimentary covers enhanced the detectability of rocks with higher magnetic properties, while the interiors showed lower magnetic anomalies due to younger sedimentary rocks. Edge detection techniques, like tilt angle and Local Wavenumber methods, improved magnetic data interpretation. The study computed Curie Point Depth and heat flow using 65 blocks, revealing greater depths in the Western Black Sea (up to 32 km) compared to the Eastern Black Sea (24-28 km). Two profiles (A-A’ and B-B’) were examined for further insights. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into the geological evolution of the Black Sea basins.
Keywords:
Curie Point Depth, Heat Flow, Tilt Derivative, Local Wavenumber, Correlation Plot.