BULLETIN OF THE MINERAL RESEARCH AND EXPLORATION (MTA Dergisi)
AUTHOR PROFILE
Articles by Kamil KAYABALI
11 PUBLICATIONS
01
Volume 176 / 2025 · Pages: 154-157
Kamil KAYABALI, Honne NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammet BEYHAN
Indexed In · Volume 176 / 2025
Reply to: “Discussion: Determination of Atterberg Limits Using the Vane Shear Test Method [Bull. Min. Res. Exp. (2024) 174: 1–10]”
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Honne NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammet BEYHAN
ABSTRACT
The main focus of the criticisms raised by O’Kelly and Soltani (2025) (hereafter referred to as discussers) to the authors’ article in Bulletin of Mineral Research and Exploration (174, 1-10) is to examine the veracity of the strength-based equations presented by Kayabalı et al. (2024). The discussers applied the predictive equations proposed by the authors to dissimilar soils in the two articles (Kayabalı et al., 2015a; Kayabalı et al., 2015b) published earlier by the lead author with his research group. The discussers showed that the predictive equations 6 and 7 given by Kayabalı et al. (2024) yield extremely high values of liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) when applied to dissimilar soils. Further, discussers argued that the approach proposed
by Kayabalı et al. (2024) led to erroneous results in determining soil classes.
An alternative approach to estimate the shear strength parameters of intact rock
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Atakan BALCI
ABSTRACT
Engineering structures built on or within rock masses require a proper characterization of their geomechanical properties. In this context, determining the strength parameters of intact rock is essential. Triaxial compression (3XC) tests are routinely employed to determine the cohesion (c) and friction angle (ϕ) of intact rocks. However, this test not only involves inherent uncertainties but also typically requires a full day to complete a single set of samples. The objective of this study is to evaluate a more practical approach for determining the c and ϕ of intact rocks. For this purpose, 20 types of intact rock were tested via 3XC, uniaxial compression (UC), and single-shear (SS) methods. The internal friction angles were determined from UC tests, while the cohesion values were obtained from SS tests. The c-ϕ pairs derived from the 3XC tests were compared with those obtained from the UC and SS tests. The results indicate that SS tests tend to overestimate cohesion compared to 3XC tests, whereas UC tests generally underestimate friction angles. Overall, the findings suggest that the proposed approach has potential as an alternative testing method in rock mechanics
Keywords:
Intact Rock, Shear Strength Parameters, Triaxial Compression Test, Uniaxial Compression Test, Single- Shear Test
Effect of degree of saturation on consolidation parameters of fine-grained soils
Authors:
Deniz YILMAZ, Kamil KAYABALI
ABSTRACT
Terzaghi (1943)’s theory of consolidation phenomenon has some limitations for unsaturated geological environments in nature. Additionally, soils are subjected to consolidation tests under partially saturation conditions. The scope of this study is to illustrate the effect of degree of saturation (Sr) on the consolidation parameters using remolded soil samples. For this purpose, swelling pressure, compression index (cc), re-compression index (cr), coefficient of consolidation (cv), and pre-consolidation stress (σp’) were determined for the samples having different degrees of saturation and plasticity (PI). The consolidation parameters obtained from “undersaturated” remolded samples with varying degrees of saturation were compared with the consolidation parameters obtained from “fully saturated” remolded samples to illustrate which parameters of consolidation are affected most by the degree of saturation. The effect of swelling of partially saturated samples was eliminated prior to conducting oedometer tests. Results indicated a meaningful relationship between the compression index and the degree of saturation, though the relationship with the recompression index was less certain. Pre-consolidation stress generally decreased as saturation increased, while no definitive trend was observed between the degree of saturation and the consolidation coefficient. Overall, most consolidation parameters were found to be somewhat affected by the degree of saturation.
Keywords:
Degree of Saturation, Coefficient of Consolidation, Pre- Consolidation Pressure, Consolidation Parameters, Compression Index, Recompression Index.
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
Indexed In · Volume 174 / 2024
Determination of Atterberg Limits using the vane shear test method
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
ABSTRACT
Atterberg limits are important index parameters used to classify soils for various engineering applications. Engineering properties of soils are predicted through simple correlations with index properties and thereby the engineering behavior of soils are qualitatively assessed. There are two popular methods of determining liquid limit, and plastic limit is commonly determined adopting rolling thread methods. To avoid operator related variations in determining plastic limit by conventional method, some researchers have explored using cone method as an alternative. However, there is no consensus about the depth of penetration to reckon the end of plastic state. Though various other test methods have been developed to determine plastic limit (like roll plate device), cone penetration with its limitation of determining plastic limit, is the only method to determine both liquid and plastic limit of soils. Since laboratory vane shear test is a simple and reliable method of determining undrained strength of fine-grained soils, the authors have explored to determine both liquid and plastic limits through correlations developed between undrained strength and water content over a range of consistencies between liquid and plastic states. This would eliminate determining liquid and plastic limit separately without sacrificing the reliability of results.
Kamil KAYABALI, Turgay BEYAZ, İlknur KARAASLAN ÖZDEMİR, Deniz YILMAZ
Indexed In · Volume 173 / 2024
A simple and practical tool for indirect determination of the unconfined compressive strength of most common construction materials
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Turgay BEYAZ, İlknur KARAASLAN ÖZDEMİR, Deniz YILMAZ
ABSTRACT
Determination of the unconfined compressive strength (UCS) of construction materials in the laboratory is tedious and time-consuming. There have been many attempts to indirectly predict UCS using simpler tools and techniques. One of them is the nail gun. The scope of this investigation is to design a nailer which can be applied all construction materials whose UCS range from 1-100 MPa. In the research, rocks, bricks, and concretes prepared in different cement/sand ratios with different strength ranges were used as materials. The unconfined compressive strength of the materials used in the experiments was first determined by conventional compression tests. The nail penetration depths were determined by conducting experiments on the same materials using a nailer with two different energy levels. An empirical relationship was developed by using nail penetration depths, driving energies, and nail diameters as the independent variables and the UCS determined by the conventional method as the dependent variable. According to the empirical relationship determined by multiple regression analysis, the UCS of building materials can be estimated with significance level of 99% by the nail penetration method. The research also revealed that the UCS of rocks might have a coefficient of variation as high as 30%.
Keywords:
Compressive strength, building materials, nail gun, driving energy.
Investigation of the coefficient of consolidation of fine-grained soils using combined apparatus
Authors:
Ramin ASADİ, Kamil KAYABALI, Mehmet Can BALCI
ABSTRACT
The scope of this investigation is to compare the coefficient of consolidation (cv) values defined by the Taylor’s Square Root of Time Fitting Method, which is obtained from the conventional oedometer tests, with the cv values calculated by Terzaghi’s One Dimensional (1D) Consolidation Theory, which is obtained from the permeability-consolidation tests performed with a combined apparatus specifically designed for this study. In addition, an empirical relation is developed to determine cv using the coefficient of permeability (k) and index properties of the soils. The cv values obtained from the permeability-consolidation tests using the combined apparatus were found to be larger than the cv values defined by the Taylor’s method, which is one of the oedometer tests. The findings showed that the difference was more prominent in the soil samples with a high plasticity. It was also found that the cv calculated by the Taylor’s method exhibited a distribution in a wide range with the increased load depending on the degree of plasticity of the soil. The cv obtained from the combined apparatus it decreased with low load values and increased with higher load levels. The cv obtained by the proposed empirical relationship showed good agreement with the cv defined by permeabilityconsolidation relationships.
https://doi.org/10.19111/bulletinofmre.835936
Keywords:
Coefficient of Consolidation, Coefficient of Permeability, Oedometer Test, Combined Apparatus.
An approach for the application of energy-based liquefaction procedure using field case history data
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Levent SELCUK, Turgay BEYAZ
ABSTRACT
This paper presents an overview to the applicability of the “energy-based liquefaction approach” with regards to the new developments in the subject. The method involves comparing the strain energy for the soil liquefaction (capacity) with the strain energy imparted to the soil layer during an earthquake (demand). The performance of the method was evaluated by using a large database of SPT-based liquefaction case history. The energy-based method and the more commonly used stressbased method were compared in their capability to assess liquefaction potential under the same damaging historic earthquakes and geotechnical site conditions. In the procedure, the predictive strain energy equations were used to estimate the capacity energy values. These empirical equations have been developed based on the initial effective soil parameters. As for the energy of any given strong ground motion, it was computed from a velocity-time history of the ground motion and the unit mass of soil through utilization of kinetic energy concepts. The proposed energy-based method has effective way in evaluating the liquefaction potential based on the seismological parameters, contrary to the stress-based approach, where only peak ground acceleration (PGA) is considered.
https://doi.org/10.19111/bulletinofmre.677626
Keywords:
Soil liquefaction, Energybased liquefaction method, Field case histories, Earthquake.
Kamil KAYABALI, Ramin ASADİ, Mustafa FENER, Orhan DİKMEN, Farhad HABİBZADEH, Özgür AKTÜRK
Indexed In · Volume 162 / 2020
Estimation of the compaction characteristics of soils using the static compaction method
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Ramin ASADİ, Mustafa FENER, Orhan DİKMEN, Farhad HABİBZADEH, Özgür AKTÜRK
ABSTRACT
Ground improvement using mechanical stabilization is commonly applied by performing the standard Proctor compaction test, which requires a significant quantity of soil, usually obtained from open pits. A static compaction test is an alternative laboratory compaction test. Although researchers have shown that the results of miniature size static compaction tests are comparable with that of standard Proctor tests in terms of the maximum dry density and the optimum water content, no attempt has been made to compare the two fundamental properties of the compacted soil: undrained shear strength and hydraulic conductivity. The scope of this investigation was to estimate the level of static compaction energy required to (1) obtain a compaction curve similar to that of the standard Proctor test; (2) reconstruct compacted soils using the standard Proctor and static compaction tests at the optimum water content; and (3) compare the undrained shear strength and hydraulic conductivity of compacted soils. The compacted soils at the predetermined energy level were subjected to hydraulic conductivity tests using the rigid-wall falling-head permeability method. Undrained shear strength tests were performed by employing a high-capacity laboratory vane shear apparatus on compacted samples of both the standard Proctor and static compaction tests. The present investigation revealed that the static compaction test, requiring about only 10% of the soil necessary to perform the standard Proctor method, provides comparable results in regard to hydraulic conductivity and undrained shear strength.
https://doi.org/10.19111/bulletinofmre.603873
Keywords:
Static compaction, Standard Proctor, Unconfined compressive strength, Permeability, Compaction energy.
Kamil KAYABALI, Pınar YILMAZ, Mustafa FENER, Ozgür AKTÜRK, Farhad HABİBZADEH
Indexed In · Volume 156 / 2018
Assessment of souil liquefaction using the energy approach
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Pınar YILMAZ, Mustafa FENER, Ozgür AKTÜRK, Farhad HABİBZADEH
ABSTRACT
Damage to structures during earthquakes may be fully or partly caused by soil liquefaction, which has been the subject of extensive research for several decades. Liquefaction susceptibility of a sandy deposit is performed by comparing the resistance of a soil to liquefaction (i.e., capacity) to the load imparted by an earthquake (i.e., demand). In this regard, the stress-based method of liquefaction assessment is by far the most popular. It involves uncertainties mostly related to the computation of the maximum horizontal ground acceleration (amax) at bedrock. A site response analysis or a simplifi ed assumption is necessary to determine the amax on the ground level as well. Developing from the stress-based approach, the strain-based approach has also similar constraints. There exist laboratory techniques such as torsional shear to determine the capacity of a sandy soil in terms of liquefaction energy per unit volume. Likewise, the energy of a strong motion record can be set by employing simple physics principles. For this, a velocity time history and the unit mass of the soil are employed to compute the demand of any strong motion record. The scope of this investigation is to illustrate the usability of the energy-based method for the evaluation of soil liquefaction. The defi ciencies of the stress- and strain-based approaches are outlined and the advantages of the energybased approach are discussed.
http://dx.doi.org/10.19111/bulletinofmre.351257
Keywords:
Liquefaction, stress method, strain method, energy method, earthquake energy,
REFINEMENT OF THE REVERSE EXTRUSION TEST TO DETERMINE THE TWO CONSISTENCY LIMITS
Authors:
Kamil Kayabalı, Ayla Bulut Üstün, Ali Özkeser
ABSTRACT
Liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) are the two most commonly used index properties of fine-grained soils. They have been used in not only classification of soils but also in correlation with certain engineering properties. Therefore, they have been subjected to numerous researches since they were first introduced by Atterberg in 1911. While their mechanisms were well defined in many codes and they have been in use for decades, criticisms often arose pertinent to the uncertainties inherent to them. Incredible amount of effort has been exerted to invent more rational testing methods in place of both the Casagrande’s cup and bead rolling methods. Part of those efforts has been on devicing a single tool to measure the two relative index properties together. Recently, the reverse extrusion test was brought into the use of geotechnical engineers. It was shown that this tool has a potential of measuring LL, PL, and even the shrinkage limit (SL). The aim of this investigation is to reassess the ability of the reverse extrusion test to determine LL and PL with further refinement. In this regard 70 finegrained soils covering a large range of plasticity were employed. Fall-cone method and rolling-device method were employed to determine LL and PL, respectively. The reverse extrusion tests were carried out at least five different water contents per soil sample. Extrusion pressures were plotted against water content and a curve fitting was applied to data pairs, from which the y-intercept (the coefficient a) and the slope (the coefficieent b) of the curve were determined. Those reverse extrusion coefficients were utilized to determine the representative extrusion pressures corresponding to LL and PL, as was done by the earlier researchers; however, the degree of success for the prediction of LL and PL using the representative extrusion pressures was not encouraging. Different from the previously proposed approaches, the reverse extrusion coefficients (i.e., a and b) were subjected to a multiple regression analysis along with the results of the conventional testing methods of fall-cone and rolling-device to determine the LL and PL as functions of the reverse extrusion parameters. It was shown that LL and PL can be predicted with a great degree of success using the reverse extrusion coefficients. While a great majority of the liquid limits found by using the fall-cone method were predicted with a ±10% error, almost all of the plastic limits found by the rolling device were predicted with a ±10% error. This refined investigation on the reverse extrusion test confirmed and proved that the reverse extrusion test is a simple, robust and inexpensive method capable of predicting both of two fundamental consistency limits using a single device.
Keywords:
Plastic Limit, Fall-Cone Mthod, Rolling-Device Method, Reverse Extrusion Test