Atterberg limits are important index parameters used to classify soils for various engineering applications. Engineering properties of soils are predicted through simple correlations with index properties and thereby the engineering behavior of soils are qualitatively assessed. There are two popular methods of determining liquid limit, and plastic limit is commonly determined adopting rolling thread methods. To avoid operator related variations in determining plastic limit by conventional method, some researchers have explored using cone method as an alternative. However, there is no consensus about the depth of penetration to reckon the end of plastic state. Though various other test methods have been developed to determine plastic limit (like roll plate device), cone penetration with its limitation of determining plastic limit, is the only method to determine both liquid and plastic limit of soils. Since laboratory vane shear test is a simple and reliable method of determining undrained strength of fine-grained soils, the authors have explored to determine both liquid and plastic limits through correlations developed between undrained strength and water content over a range of consistencies between liquid and plastic states. This would eliminate determining liquid and plastic limit separately without sacrificing the reliability of results.
Kamil KAYABALI, Honne NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammet BEYHAN
Indexed In · Volume 176 / April 2025
Reply to: “Discussion: Determination of Atterberg Limits Using the Vane Shear Test Method [Bull. Min. Res. Exp. (2024) 174: 1–10]”
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, Honne NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammet BEYHAN
ABSTRACT
The main focus of the criticisms raised by O’Kelly and Soltani (2025) (hereafter referred to as discussers) to the authors’ article in Bulletin of Mineral Research and Exploration (174, 1-10) is to examine the veracity of the strength-based equations presented by Kayabalı et al. (2024). The discussers applied the predictive equations proposed by the authors to dissimilar soils in the two articles (Kayabalı et al., 2015a; Kayabalı et al., 2015b) published earlier by the lead author with his research group. The discussers showed that the predictive equations 6 and 7 given by Kayabalı et al. (2024) yield extremely high values of liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) when applied to dissimilar soils. Further, discussers argued that the approach proposed
by Kayabalı et al. (2024) led to erroneous results in determining soil classes.
Discussion: Determination of Atterberg Limits Using the Vane Shear Test Method [Bull. Min. Res. Exp. (2024) 174: 1–10]
Authors:
Brendan O’KELLY, Amin SOLTANI
ABSTRACT
This article presents a discussion of the original research reported in the paper by Kayabalı et al. (2024) (the Authors) that was recently published in the Bulletin of the Mineral Research and Exploration Vol. 174, pp. 1–10. Using liquid limit (LL), plastic limit (PL) and vane shear strength against water content [i.e., su(VST)–w] results obtained for 100 fine-grained soil samples, the Authors performed multiple regression analyses to produce four strength-based correlations for predicting the LL and PL values based on su(VST)–w measurements. The Authors’ dataset primarily consisted of residual soils formed through the weathering of igneous rocks, along with a few lacustrine soil samples, all sourced from the vicinity of Ankara, Türkiye. This discussion article examines the veracity of the Authors’ claims regarding the predictive performance of their proposed correlations when applied to other fine-grained soils. Using a sizable independent database of dissimilar fine-grained soils compiled from the research literature, it is conclusively shown that, contrary to the Authors’ assertions, their proposed correlations generally produce poor LL and PL predictions when employed beyond the calibration soil types. This outcome is not unexpected, since the Authors’ data-driven correlations were deduced based on a specific dataset with limited diversity in terms of soil physico-chemical and mineralogical attributes. The article closes with a discussion of the plausible explanations for the poor applicability of the Authors’ correlations when apllied to dissimilar fine-grained soils.
REFINEMENT OF THE REVERSE EXTRUSION TEST TO DETERMINE THE TWO CONSISTENCY LIMITS
Authors:
Kamil Kayabalı, Ayla Bulut Üstün, Ali Özkeser
ABSTRACT
Liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) are the two most commonly used index properties of fine-grained soils. They have been used in not only classification of soils but also in correlation with certain engineering properties. Therefore, they have been subjected to numerous researches since they were first introduced by Atterberg in 1911. While their mechanisms were well defined in many codes and they have been in use for decades, criticisms often arose pertinent to the uncertainties inherent to them. Incredible amount of effort has been exerted to invent more rational testing methods in place of both the Casagrande’s cup and bead rolling methods. Part of those efforts has been on devicing a single tool to measure the two relative index properties together. Recently, the reverse extrusion test was brought into the use of geotechnical engineers. It was shown that this tool has a potential of measuring LL, PL, and even the shrinkage limit (SL). The aim of this investigation is to reassess the ability of the reverse extrusion test to determine LL and PL with further refinement. In this regard 70 finegrained soils covering a large range of plasticity were employed. Fall-cone method and rolling-device method were employed to determine LL and PL, respectively. The reverse extrusion tests were carried out at least five different water contents per soil sample. Extrusion pressures were plotted against water content and a curve fitting was applied to data pairs, from which the y-intercept (the coefficient a) and the slope (the coefficieent b) of the curve were determined. Those reverse extrusion coefficients were utilized to determine the representative extrusion pressures corresponding to LL and PL, as was done by the earlier researchers; however, the degree of success for the prediction of LL and PL using the representative extrusion pressures was not encouraging. Different from the previously proposed approaches, the reverse extrusion coefficients (i.e., a and b) were subjected to a multiple regression analysis along with the results of the conventional testing methods of fall-cone and rolling-device to determine the LL and PL as functions of the reverse extrusion parameters. It was shown that LL and PL can be predicted with a great degree of success using the reverse extrusion coefficients. While a great majority of the liquid limits found by using the fall-cone method were predicted with a ±10% error, almost all of the plastic limits found by the rolling device were predicted with a ±10% error. This refined investigation on the reverse extrusion test confirmed and proved that the reverse extrusion test is a simple, robust and inexpensive method capable of predicting both of two fundamental consistency limits using a single device.
Keywords:
Plastic Limit, Fall-Cone Mthod, Rolling-Device Method, Reverse Extrusion Test
Determination of the relationship between tectonic and karstification using morphometric indices in Bozburun Peninsula, Marmaris, Türkiye
Authors:
İsmail EGE, Efekan ÖZKAN, Selahattin POLAT
ABSTRACT
Bozburun Peninsula (Marmaris) attracts attention due to its various karst shapes on limestones of different ages. It is also located in an important region in terms of tectonic activity. In this study, the distribution of karst shapes determined by satellite images, topographic maps and field studies was examined. In this context, the elevation ranges (m), base and hillslope angles (%), depth (m) and pitting rates (RP), elongation ratio (RE) and directions (EA α) of the relevant shapes were determined. Then, the relationship between the faults and the quantitative results obtained was interpreted. Remote Sensing (RS), Geographic Information System (GIS) technologies, calculations and field observations used in the study; it enabled us to reveal that there is a close relationship between karstic formations such as polje, uvala and doline and geological structures such as faults, diaclasis, folds and Nappe windows. Available data also show that geological structures have a positive effect on karstification in the study area.
Archaeoseismology: Earthquake traces studies in ancient settlements; a chronological evaluation from the World focusing on Türkiye
Authors:
Ökmen SÜMER, Volkan KARABACAK
ABSTRACT
Archaeoseismology is a field of science that investigates the remains of ancient human structures of destructive earthquakes that occurred in their ancient history and in this respect makes inferences on the possible effects of earthquakes whose origins will be may occurred in the future. Although many authors wrote the effects of ancient earthquakes in various periods, the first modern archaeoseismology studies in the world gain momentum starting from the end of the 19th century at the same time with Türkiye. In this understanding, the geography of Anatolia (Asia Minor), which has hosted a wide variety of cultural layers since its Mesolithic end, is an open-air research laboratory for modern archaeoseismological studies. This study is a reference work that summarizes the historical past of the discipline of archaeoseismology chronologically in the perspective of studies on Earth and Anatolia, presents suggestions about the future of archaeoseismology and is a literature summary for the new generation of archaeoseismologists.
Keywords:
Archaeoseismology, Archaeoseismologist, Ancient human structures, Chronological development, Anatolia.
Meeting freshwater demands in water-scarce regions is imperative, given challenges like hydric stress, urbanization, aridity, and population growth. This study focuses on the Tebessa aquifer system, a critical water source facing escalating demands. A primary objective is to identify actionable management strategies to improve groundwater quality dynamics in semi-arid regions. The methodology involves a comprehensive assessment of groundwater health using the Water Quality Index (WQI) approach. This method integrates diverse parameters influenced by intensive agricultural and industrial activities. Additionally, spatial relationship analysis, facilitated by Geographic Information System (GIS) technology, is employed to gain insights into complex hydrogeological processes. The multi-parameter strategy implemented results in water quality maps that highlight various ions, revealing spatial disparities and assigning quality priority classes from ‘Good’ to ‘Poor’ across the groundwater. The research, conducted in the semi-arid Tebessa-Morsott Plain, encompasses field and laboratory investigations to delineate hydrochemical traits, including alkalinity, salinity, and heightened ion concentrations. The results of the study contribute to scientific understanding by uncovering interrelationships and spatial intricacies, offering valuable insights for water resource governance. The effectiveness of the methodology, incorporating WQI and GIS, is demonstrated in the comprehensive evaluation of groundwater quality. Ultimately, this research provides a foundation for informed decision-making and sustainable management of groundwater resources in semi-arid regions.
Keywords:
Freshwater Demands, Water Quality Index WQI, Aquifer, Hydrogeological Processes, Chemical Parameters.