This article presents a discussion of the original research reported in the paper by Kayabalı et al. (2024) (the Authors) that was recently published in the Bulletin of the Mineral Research and Exploration Vol. 174, pp. 1–10. Using liquid limit (LL), plastic limit (PL) and vane shear strength against water content [i.e., su(VST)–w] results obtained for 100 fine-grained soil samples, the Authors performed multiple regression analyses to produce four strength-based correlations for predicting the LL and PL values based on su(VST)–w measurements. The Authors’ dataset primarily consisted of residual soils formed through the weathering of igneous rocks, along with a few lacustrine soil samples, all sourced from the vicinity of Ankara, Türkiye. This discussion article examines the veracity of the Authors’ claims regarding the predictive performance of their proposed correlations when applied to other fine-grained soils. Using a sizable independent database of dissimilar fine-grained soils compiled from the research literature, it is conclusively shown that, contrary to the Authors’ assertions, their proposed correlations generally produce poor LL and PL predictions when employed beyond the calibration soil types. This outcome is not unexpected, since the Authors’ data-driven correlations were deduced based on a specific dataset with limited diversity in terms of soil physico-chemical and mineralogical attributes. The article closes with a discussion of the plausible explanations for the poor applicability of the Authors’ correlations when apllied to dissimilar fine-grained soils.
Effect of degree of saturation on consolidation parameters of fine-grained soils
Authors:
Deniz YILMAZ, Kamil KAYABALI
ABSTRACT
Terzaghi (1943)’s theory of consolidation phenomenon has some limitations for unsaturated geological environments in nature. Additionally, soils are subjected to consolidation tests under partially saturation conditions. The scope of this study is to illustrate the effect of degree of saturation (Sr) on the consolidation parameters using remolded soil samples. For this purpose, swelling pressure, compression index (cc), re-compression index (cr), coefficient of consolidation (cv), and pre-consolidation stress (σp’) were determined for the samples having different degrees of saturation and plasticity (PI). The consolidation parameters obtained from “undersaturated” remolded samples with varying degrees of saturation were compared with the consolidation parameters obtained from “fully saturated” remolded samples to illustrate which parameters of consolidation are affected most by the degree of saturation. The effect of swelling of partially saturated samples was eliminated prior to conducting oedometer tests. Results indicated a meaningful relationship between the compression index and the degree of saturation, though the relationship with the recompression index was less certain. Pre-consolidation stress generally decreased as saturation increased, while no definitive trend was observed between the degree of saturation and the consolidation coefficient. Overall, most consolidation parameters were found to be somewhat affected by the degree of saturation.
Keywords:
Degree of Saturation, Coefficient of Consolidation, Pre- Consolidation Pressure, Consolidation Parameters, Compression Index, Recompression Index.
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
Indexed In · Volume 174 / August 2024
Determination of Atterberg Limits using the vane shear test method
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
ABSTRACT
Atterberg limits are important index parameters used to classify soils for various engineering applications. Engineering properties of soils are predicted through simple correlations with index properties and thereby the engineering behavior of soils are qualitatively assessed. There are two popular methods of determining liquid limit, and plastic limit is commonly determined adopting rolling thread methods. To avoid operator related variations in determining plastic limit by conventional method, some researchers have explored using cone method as an alternative. However, there is no consensus about the depth of penetration to reckon the end of plastic state. Though various other test methods have been developed to determine plastic limit (like roll plate device), cone penetration with its limitation of determining plastic limit, is the only method to determine both liquid and plastic limit of soils. Since laboratory vane shear test is a simple and reliable method of determining undrained strength of fine-grained soils, the authors have explored to determine both liquid and plastic limits through correlations developed between undrained strength and water content over a range of consistencies between liquid and plastic states. This would eliminate determining liquid and plastic limit separately without sacrificing the reliability of results.
Investigation of the coefficient of consolidation of fine-grained soils using combined apparatus
Authors:
Ramin ASADİ, Kamil KAYABALI, Mehmet Can BALCI
ABSTRACT
The scope of this investigation is to compare the coefficient of consolidation (cv) values defined by the Taylor’s Square Root of Time Fitting Method, which is obtained from the conventional oedometer tests, with the cv values calculated by Terzaghi’s One Dimensional (1D) Consolidation Theory, which is obtained from the permeability-consolidation tests performed with a combined apparatus specifically designed for this study. In addition, an empirical relation is developed to determine cv using the coefficient of permeability (k) and index properties of the soils. The cv values obtained from the permeability-consolidation tests using the combined apparatus were found to be larger than the cv values defined by the Taylor’s method, which is one of the oedometer tests. The findings showed that the difference was more prominent in the soil samples with a high plasticity. It was also found that the cv calculated by the Taylor’s method exhibited a distribution in a wide range with the increased load depending on the degree of plasticity of the soil. The cv obtained from the combined apparatus it decreased with low load values and increased with higher load levels. The cv obtained by the proposed empirical relationship showed good agreement with the cv defined by permeabilityconsolidation relationships.
https://doi.org/10.19111/bulletinofmre.835936
Keywords:
Coefficient of Consolidation, Coefficient of Permeability, Oedometer Test, Combined Apparatus.
Effect of degree of saturation on consolidation parameters of fine-grained soils
Authors:
Deniz YILMAZ, Kamil KAYABALI
ABSTRACT
Terzaghi (1943)’s theory of consolidation phenomenon has some limitations for unsaturated geological environments in nature. Additionally, soils are subjected to consolidation tests under partially saturation conditions. The scope of this study is to illustrate the effect of degree of saturation (Sr) on the consolidation parameters using remolded soil samples. For this purpose, swelling pressure, compression index (cc), re-compression index (cr), coefficient of consolidation (cv), and pre-consolidation stress (σp’) were determined for the samples having different degrees of saturation and plasticity (PI). The consolidation parameters obtained from “undersaturated” remolded samples with varying degrees of saturation were compared with the consolidation parameters obtained from “fully saturated” remolded samples to illustrate which parameters of consolidation are affected most by the degree of saturation. The effect of swelling of partially saturated samples was eliminated prior to conducting oedometer tests. Results indicated a meaningful relationship between the compression index and the degree of saturation, though the relationship with the recompression index was less certain. Pre-consolidation stress generally decreased as saturation increased, while no definitive trend was observed between the degree of saturation and the consolidation coefficient. Overall, most consolidation parameters were found to be somewhat affected by the degree of saturation.
Keywords:
Degree of Saturation, Coefficient of Consolidation, Pre- Consolidation Pressure, Consolidation Parameters, Compression Index, Recompression Index.
Mehmet ÇÖTELİ, Mustafa ALBAYRAK, Ufuk KİBAR, Arzu YAVUZ, Gülsüm TURGUT, Duran Serdar KARAHAN
Indexed In · Volume 176 / April 2025
Mineralogical examination of biomass ashes: A preliminary study for potassium enrichment and phosphoric acid (H3PO4) production
Authors:
Mehmet ÇÖTELİ, Mustafa ALBAYRAK, Ufuk KİBAR, Arzu YAVUZ, Gülsüm TURGUT, Duran Serdar KARAHAN
ABSTRACT
In this study, biomass fly ash was investigated and determined by XRD (XRay Diffractometer) to be predominantly langbeinite, aphthitalite, sylvine, apatite and hydroxyapatite. An alkaline leaching study was carried out on the material in a glass reactor at l/s ratio 4 temperature 60°C at pH 12.85 and after drying was analyzed by ICP (Inducted couple plasma). The crystal structure composition of K2SO4 72.28% and potassium content of 33.47% (w/w) was recovered. The elemental transformations in this leaching process were: K 74.16%, Mg 0.55% was found to be 0.8%. It was found that a minimum of 4.84 g H2SO4 per 100 g fly ash was required to precipitate the Ca(OH)2 migrated into the liquid solution and the overall leaching efficiency was found to be 29.85%. In the alkaline leaching process, potassium was found to be easily recovered from each biomass ash. By adding 40 g H2SO4/100 g biomass waste remaining after leaching, a phosphorus recovery of 74.9% was observed. In this preliminary study, unsatisfactory results were obtained in obtaining the industry standard H3PO4. The reason for this is that the Al, Mg and K in the fly ash are subject to selective dissolution as a result of working at high pH in the alkaline leaching process.
Magnetic anomalies and geological signatures in the Black Sea: a comprehensive study of the east and west basins
Authors:
İlkin ÖZSÖZ, Eşref AYLAN, Ceyhan Ertan TOKER
ABSTRACT
This study investigates the origin of the Black Sea, focusing on the East and West Black Sea basins. Data such as Curie Point Depth values, heat flow, bathymetry, Moho depth, sediment thickness, and magnetic depth estimation were analyzed to explore the region’s geological features. Correlations between these parameters were assessed for each basin, shedding light on their tectonic history and the influence of volcanic rocks. Thinner sedimentary covers enhanced the detectability of rocks with higher magnetic properties, while the interiors showed lower magnetic anomalies due to younger sedimentary rocks. Edge detection techniques, like tilt angle and Local Wavenumber methods, improved magnetic data interpretation. The study computed Curie Point Depth and heat flow using 65 blocks, revealing greater depths in the Western Black Sea (up to 32 km) compared to the Eastern Black Sea (24-28 km). Two profiles (A-A’ and B-B’) were examined for further insights. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into the geological evolution of the Black Sea basins.
Keywords:
Curie Point Depth, Heat Flow, Tilt Derivative, Local Wavenumber, Correlation Plot.