Plastic Limit, Fall-Cone Mthod, Rolling-Device Method, Reverse Extrusion Test
Abstract:
Liquid limit (LL) and plastic limit (PL) are the two most commonly used index properties of fine-grained soils. They have been used in not only classification of soils but also in correlation with certain engineering properties. Therefore, they have been subjected to numerous researches since they were first introduced by Atterberg in 1911. While their mechanisms were well defined in many codes and they have been in use for decades, criticisms often arose pertinent to the uncertainties inherent to them. Incredible amount of effort has been exerted to invent more rational testing methods in place of both the Casagrande’s cup and bead rolling methods. Part of those efforts has been on devicing a single tool to measure the two relative index properties together. Recently, the reverse extrusion test was brought into the use of geotechnical engineers. It was shown that this tool has a potential of measuring LL, PL, and even the shrinkage limit (SL). The aim of this investigation is to reassess the ability of the reverse extrusion test to determine LL and PL with further refinement. In this regard 70 finegrained soils covering a large range of plasticity were employed. Fall-cone method and rolling-device method were employed to determine LL and PL, respectively. The reverse extrusion tests were carried out at least five different water contents per soil sample. Extrusion pressures were plotted against water content and a curve fitting was applied to data pairs, from which the y-intercept (the coefficient a) and the slope (the coefficieent b) of the curve were determined. Those reverse extrusion coefficients were utilized to determine the representative extrusion pressures corresponding to LL and PL, as was done by the earlier researchers; however, the degree of success for the prediction of LL and PL using the representative extrusion pressures was not encouraging. Different from the previously proposed approaches, the reverse extrusion coefficients (i.e., a and b) were subjected to a multiple regression analysis along with the results of the conventional testing methods of fall-cone and rolling-device to determine the LL and PL as functions of the reverse extrusion parameters. It was shown that LL and PL can be predicted with a great degree of success using the reverse extrusion coefficients. While a great majority of the liquid limits found by using the fall-cone method were predicted with a ±10% error, almost all of the plastic limits found by the rolling device were predicted with a ±10% error. This refined investigation on the reverse extrusion test confirmed and proved that the reverse extrusion test is a simple, robust and inexpensive method capable of predicting both of two fundamental consistency limits using a single device.
Discussion: Determination of Atterberg Limits Using the Vane Shear Test Method [Bull. Min. Res. Exp. (2024) 174: 1–10]
Authors:
Brendan O’KELLY, Amin SOLTANI
ABSTRACT
This article presents a discussion of the original research reported in the paper by Kayabalı et al. (2024) (the Authors) that was recently published in the Bulletin of the Mineral Research and Exploration Vol. 174, pp. 1–10. Using liquid limit (LL), plastic limit (PL) and vane shear strength against water content [i.e., su(VST)–w] results obtained for 100 fine-grained soil samples, the Authors performed multiple regression analyses to produce four strength-based correlations for predicting the LL and PL values based on su(VST)–w measurements. The Authors’ dataset primarily consisted of residual soils formed through the weathering of igneous rocks, along with a few lacustrine soil samples, all sourced from the vicinity of Ankara, Türkiye. This discussion article examines the veracity of the Authors’ claims regarding the predictive performance of their proposed correlations when applied to other fine-grained soils. Using a sizable independent database of dissimilar fine-grained soils compiled from the research literature, it is conclusively shown that, contrary to the Authors’ assertions, their proposed correlations generally produce poor LL and PL predictions when employed beyond the calibration soil types. This outcome is not unexpected, since the Authors’ data-driven correlations were deduced based on a specific dataset with limited diversity in terms of soil physico-chemical and mineralogical attributes. The article closes with a discussion of the plausible explanations for the poor applicability of the Authors’ correlations when apllied to dissimilar fine-grained soils.
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
Indexed In · Volume 174 / August 2024
Determination of Atterberg Limits using the vane shear test method
Authors:
Kamil KAYABALI, H. B. NAGARAJ, Deniz YILMAZ, Muhammed BEYHAN
ABSTRACT
Atterberg limits are important index parameters used to classify soils for various engineering applications. Engineering properties of soils are predicted through simple correlations with index properties and thereby the engineering behavior of soils are qualitatively assessed. There are two popular methods of determining liquid limit, and plastic limit is commonly determined adopting rolling thread methods. To avoid operator related variations in determining plastic limit by conventional method, some researchers have explored using cone method as an alternative. However, there is no consensus about the depth of penetration to reckon the end of plastic state. Though various other test methods have been developed to determine plastic limit (like roll plate device), cone penetration with its limitation of determining plastic limit, is the only method to determine both liquid and plastic limit of soils. Since laboratory vane shear test is a simple and reliable method of determining undrained strength of fine-grained soils, the authors have explored to determine both liquid and plastic limits through correlations developed between undrained strength and water content over a range of consistencies between liquid and plastic states. This would eliminate determining liquid and plastic limit separately without sacrificing the reliability of results.
The benthic foraminiferal biostratigraphy of Oligo-Miocene aged Muratlı and Petekkaya formations which crop out over wide regions around Akçadağ town, west of Malatya province in Eastern Taurids were revealed in this study. Systematical sampling was carried out in measured stratigraphical sections in four locations in order to perform stratigraphical and paleontological investigations. Benthic foraminifera taken from 182 hard rock samples were defined and three biozones were determined as; SBZ 21-22, belonging to Oligocene (Rupelian - Early Chattian), SBZ 23 (Late Chattian) and SBZ 25 belonging to Lower Miocene in shallow marine deposits in the region. It was stated that the assemblage of planktic foraminifer and nannoplankton which stratigraphically detected within Chattian - Burdigalian units in the succession most probably indicated Aquitanian age. Besides; Oligo-Miocene transition in the region was approved with this study based on biostratigraphical locations of benthic foraminiferal taxa.
Alireza ALMASİ, Alireza JAFARİRAD, Peyman AFZAL, Mana RAHİMİ
Indexed In · Volume 150 / 2015
OROGENIC GOLD PROSPECTIVITY MAPPING USING GEOSPATIAL DATA INTEGRATION, REGION OF SAQEZ, NW OF IRAN
Authors:
Alireza ALMASİ, Alireza JAFARİRAD, Peyman AFZAL, Mana RAHİMİ
ABSTRACT
The aim of this study is to map orogenic gold prospecting areas in the region of Saqez, NW of Iran. In order to achieve this task geological, geochemical and airborne geophysical data are analyzed and integrated using index overlay and fuzzy logic methods. Geological map of Saqez (1:100.000 scale) is used to assign lithological weights based on their favorability for hosting orogenic Au mineralization. Also a fault density map is produced and assigned based on the structural map which is included in the geological map. For preparing geochemical evidence maps, data from 535 stream sediment samples are examined using Number-Size multifractal method for Au, As, Bi and Hg. The detected thresholds are used to assign the catchment basins of the stream sediment samples. Aeromagnetic data is employed to detect the edges of magnetic anomalies based on an enhanced edge detection method. Extracted lineaments are then converted to a density map and assigned properly. Airborne radiometric data is also used to produce two evidence maps. Potassium count grid independently and K/Th ratio map are employed to distinguish locations with hydrothermal activity. Finally after integrating evidence maps, new locations with high potentials of Au mineralization are identified considering that the gold indications of the study area (Qolqoleh, Kervian and Ghabaghloujeh) are placed in the first priority of the fuzzy logic prospectivity map.
Doğan PERİNÇEK, Nurdan ATAS, Seyma KARATUT, Esra ERENSOY
Indexed In · Volume 150 / 2015
GEOLOGICAL FACTORS CONTROLLING POTENTIAL OF LIGNITE BEDS WITHIN THE DANIŞMEN FORMATION IN THE THRACE BASIN
Authors:
Doğan PERİNÇEK, Nurdan ATAS, Seyma KARATUT, Esra ERENSOY
ABSTRACT
This project has been conducted for the General Directorate of Turkish Coal Enterprise. The aim of this study is to understand lignite potential of the basin. Subsurface data ( including numerous wells and several seismic lines) provided by TPAO, MTA and TKİ were used. Structure and thickness maps of Oligocene-Miocene-Pliocene units prepared for the basin. Purpose of this work is to understand economical values of lignite seam beds interbedding in the Danişmen Formation (Oligocene-Early Miocene). For this purpose, from bottom to top following maps were prepared: Structural map of the top Osmancık (Oligocene) Formation, thickness map of the Danişmen Formation, paleo-topographic map of unconformity surface which is at the top of the Danişmen Formation, total thickness map of Ergene-Kırcasalih formations (Late Miocene-Pliocene). Finally total thickness map of the lignite layers was prepared. It was the main purpose of the work. Lignite seam layers are located in middle of the Danişmen Formation. Also several stratigraphic correlations were conducted to understand lateral continuation of lignite layers. The first obstacle to reach lignite is thickness of the Ergene and Kırcasalih formations which overlie lignite bearing Danişmen Formation. Main structural event controlling the thickness variation of the Danişmen Formation is Thrace Fault System (Perinçek, 1991); it was active during Middle Miocene. Danişmen Formation extensively or partially was eroded along the fault zone and on the en-echelon folds of the fault system. Amount of erosion is variable and in some areas Danişmen Formation completely was eroded. As a result Ergene Formation lies directly on Osmancık Formation. Lignite layers are also eroded at these localities. Elevated areas related the Thrace Fault System partially was eroded; however these areas were still paleo-elevated areas during the accumulation of Ergene Formation. Onlapping sequence of Ergene Formation is thinner on these areas. At the end of this project, thicker lignite areas were delineated. Addition to this, thin overburden areas on lignite are located. Considering these result, new permit areas were selected.. In order to refine this work, a suggested facies map of Danişmen Formation is advise to be prepared.